National parks budget mostly a shell game
Oregon Register-Guard
March 2, 2007
GUEST VIEWPOINT
By Robert Mutch
Given the glowing reviews of President Bush’s proposed 2008 budget for national parks in a Feb. 21 Register-Guard editorial and elsewhere, and anticipating National Park Service Secretary Mary Bomar’s visit to Capitol Hill to sell this plan, we should carefully scrutinize the budget first and see what facts we can glean from it.
Of the proposed $230 million “increase” in park operations, $211 million is actually at the expense of other national park programs. The old shell game is done today with a spreadsheet. A closer look shows that maintenance and construction, historic preservation, state assistance and land acquisition will be reduced; the budget moves money around rather than increasing overall benefits.
Our second concern is a proposal that would match potential private contributions with tax dollars, dollar for dollar, up to $100 million a year for 10 years. This drastically alters the way we have funded our national parks for more than 100 years.
This plan forces the park manager into the role of panhandler.
With a mandate to reach the annual goal of $100 million in donations, managers may seek donations from sources beyond the appropriate philanthropic ones. This could open the door to less altruistic investors in our national parks. Over time, this could result in parks being far less public and far more private.
Look what has happened to public television, which now replaces vanishing government funding with commercials. So, too, might sponsors advertise themselves in the parks.
These donors also might feel they have the right to dictate how parks are to be maintained and operated. Philanthropy quickly could turn into philandering.
The long and proud tradition of true philanthropy in national parks should always be considered an added value, above the necessary core level of publicly funded service and protection in our national parks. Voluntary contributions should never be construed as a replacement for federal support.
Requiring the National Park Service to find private sector funds to support basic capital improvements and maintenance also could skew which projects get done. There likely will be greater emphasis on “show me” projects to honor private investors – such as new visitor centers or rehabilitation of prominent historic sites, rather than meeting dire park infrastructure needs, such as utilities or roads.
In our analysis, the overall increase in “new” money for the national parks is only 2 percent above 2006 levels. By contrast, the 2007 cost of living adjustment for Social Security was 3.3 percent.
William Steel dedicated much of his life to getting Crater Lake established as a national park, ensuring it was protected from special interests and helping visitors to appreciate its extraordinary beauty. Many others following in his footsteps have given much – educators, scientists and concerned citizens.
Let us in turn follow in their footsteps and ensure that Crater Lake remains our park for generations to come.
Robert Mutch (robmutch@yahoo.com) of Eugene is executive director of the Crater Lake Institute. Ron Mastrogiuseppe of Agency Lake, president of the institute, and Owen Hoffman of Tennessee, a member of the institute board, helped prepare this essay. The Crater Lake Institute’s Web site is at www.craterlakeinstitute.com.
Other pages in this section
- Gorgeous and Free: free, guided snowshoe hikes – December 27, 2007
- Chief Ranger Dave Brennan Retires This Month – December 31, 2007
- Finding Your Winter Wonderland – December 15, 2007
- Exploring Crater Lake in Winter: Volunteers Answer Pressing Questions – December 15, 2007
- A part of history: Annual Great Nordeen cross-country ski race links the past to the present – December 15, 2007
- Crater Lake Chief Ranger to Retire: Dave Brennan has been on the job for 7 1/2 years – December 3, 2007
- Into the Deep: Crater Lake’s ranking as one of the world’s deepest lakes varies by how list is determined – November 29, 2007
- Where to go for Thanksgiving snow: Mount Hood, Crater Lake offer best bets – November 21, 2007
- Lundy happy with progress at Crater Lake park – November 12, 2007
- Plotting a new course: Crater Lake superintendent Chuck Lundy to retire next year – November 12, 2007
- A bit of history – November 12, 2007
- Delegation Supporting Visitor Center at Crater Lake – November 11, 2007
- Walden, DeFazio Voice Support – November 11, 2007
- Crater Rim Drive closes Friday evening – November 7, 2007
- Follow-up on 2005 Ranger-Involved Shooting – November 5, 2007
- Source of the Rogue – November 01, 2007
- Unanimous Oregon Delegation Requests $2.5 Million for Crater Lake Visitor Center – October 31, 2007
- Crater Lake Seeks Volunteers – October 27, 2007
- Screaming wind downs forest trees: Crater Lake park, Prospect area hit by gusts of up to 60 mph – October 27, 2007
- Crater Lake Ski Patrol looking for members – October 18, 2007
- Crater Lake offers a compelling glimpse of the changing seasons – October 04, 2007
- Survival of the fittest for our man in Patagonia – September 30, 2007
- Crater Lake deep yields mysterious moss – September 15, 2007
- Cycle Oregon: This year’s tour includes Diamond, Crater Lakes – September 12, 2007
- Bicyclers pedal and party their way through state – September 10, 2007
- Fairview woman dies in Jeep accident near Crater Lake – September 03, 2007
- Remains of Long Missing Body at Crater Lake – August 29, 2007
- Free Admission Saturday – August 24, 2007
- Crater Lake Rim Runs Recap – August 13, 2007
- Runs Bring Out Veterans – August 13, 2007
- Runners Chase Personal Bests, Shed Baggage – August 12, 2007
- Pine Beetles Infest Crater Lake Rim – August 11, 2007
- See Crater Lake Panorama From Atop Garfield Peak – August 10, 2007
- Little-visited Sphagnum Bog a hotbed for botanists – August 6, 2007
- Crater Lake’s Mystery Moss – August 01, 2007
- Travelers Find Solace in Sights, Scenery – July 29, 2007
- Since You Asked: Espey Had Quite a Life – July 28, 2007
- Thinning to Cause Delays – July 19, 2007
- He made movies in Brooklyn, over 100 years ago – July 5, 2007
- Blue-green algae detected in Lemolo Lake – June 26, 2007
- Annie Springs Campground – June 17, 2007
- Cycle Oregon 2007: The Week Ride – Jun 3, 2007
- Crater Lake northern entrance opens today – May 24, 2007
- Mountain Climber Brian Smith – May 24, 2007
- Shadow Everest: Brian Smith – April 27, 2007
- Unraveling the secret of Crater Lake’s … Deep Moss – April 2, 2007
- National Park Service Listening Session: Gatlinburg, Tennessee – March 14, 2007
- Rainier third most dangerous U.S. volcano, USGS says – February 28, 2007
- New ‘America the Beautiful’ pass stirs controversy – February 23rd, 2007
- Post-Kim task force helps in finding man – February 21, 2007
- Oregon Public Broadcasting’s Oregon Experience Profiles William Steel, the “Father of Crater Lake” – February 13, 2007
- Task force formed to improve search efforts – February 11, 2007
- DeFazio wants Interior to rethink Crater Lake fee hike – January 3, 2007
- Keep parks affordable – January 3, 2007
- DeFazio Urges Interior Secretary to Reconsider Hike in Park Fees – January 2, 2007
- DeFazio against parks fee increase – January 2, 2007